Why did I stop coaching online clients through spreadsheets and WhatsApp?

I lost a client’s deadlift video for nine days, and realised my system only worked in the weeks when my memory did.

Bailey Carter coaches strength training in Leeds and online, mostly for busy people who are sure they have no time. She coaches her 14 online clients on hiignite and pays for her plan like any other coach.

This post is about why I moved my 14 online clients off Google Sheets and WhatsApp and onto a coaching app called hiignite. The short answer: I lost a client’s deadlift video for nine days, and I realised my system only worked in the weeks when my memory did.

If you coach even three or four people online, I think this will happen to you at some point. So here’s how it went for me.

I lost a deadlift video for nine days

In March my client Marcus sent me a video of his deadlift on a Tuesday night. He wanted to know if his lower back was rounding at 110 kg.

I saw the notification while I was coaching someone in the gym. I thought “I’ll watch that tonight”. Then his chat filled up with messages about a holiday, a rescheduled call and a photo of his dog.

I found the video nine days later. By then he had done three more deadlift sessions without an answer from me. His back was rounding a little, by the way. Nothing dramatic, but he’d been guessing for three sessions, and that was my fault.

My old setup was one Google Sheet per client

Here’s what I was running:

  • One Google Sheet per client, with a tab for each training block
  • WhatsApp for everything else: questions, videos, check-ins
  • A notebook where I wrote down who I owed a reply to

This worked up to about six clients. At 14, my Sunday admin took around three hours. I timed it for four weeks:

  • Week 1: 2h50
  • Week 2: 3h20
  • Week 3: 3h05
  • Week 4: 2h45

Most of that time was not coaching. It was scrolling through chats to find out what people had done that week.

I expected a coaching app to be a slower spreadsheet

I’d tried a coaching app a few years back and gave up after a week. Building a program in it took longer than my sheet did.

So I expected two things from hiignite: that it would be a spreadsheet with extra clicks, and that moving 14 programs over would eat a whole weekend. I was wrong about the first and half wrong about the second.

Things that surprised me

  • Form-check videos get their own queue. Every video a client sends lands in a list where I mark it pending, reviewed or archived, and my notes attach to a timestamp in the clip. Marcus’s video would have sat under “pending” until I dealt with it. This is the feature that made me switch.
  • I didn’t retype my programs. My old sheets went in through an import that works with ChatGPT or Claude. I still read every program by hand afterwards, about 20 minutes per client. I don’t trust any import until I’ve checked it.
  • I get a summary after each workout. When a client finishes, I’m told how long it took, the sets, the volume and how hard it felt. Volume means total weight lifted: sets times reps times load. That replaced most of my chat-scrolling.
  • Logging a set is one tap. Clients tick off each set in the phone app with a single tap. Sheila, my least techy client, got it on day one!

What it costs me

I’m on the Pro plan, which is $29 a month for 10 clients, plus $6 a month for my next block of 10. So 14 clients costs me $35 a month.

I started on the trial. I used it to test with three clients before I moved everyone.

Things I still do by hand

  • Food tracking. The app has no nutrition or macro tracking right now. My two clients who track food still send me screenshots.
  • Session packs. Billing only handles monthly subscriptions, so prepaid packs are out. I sell in-person sessions in blocks of 10, and those still go on an invoice.
  • Backups. I can’t export all my coaching data in one go yet. This one worries me a bit.

What I got wrong

I told my clients on a Friday and moved them on the Monday, in the middle of their training blocks. Two of them didn’t install the app for a week and kept messaging me on WhatsApp. So for a week I had two systems, which is worse than one bad one.

If I did it again, I’d switch each person at the start of a new block.

My Sunday admin is now about 1h20. I can’t tell you how much of that is the app. I also tidied up every program while I was moving it, and that probably helped too.

What I still don’t know

  • Does this hold up at 30 clients, or does the review queue become its own inbox to dread?
  • Are my clients messaging me less because everything is in one place, or because the app is new and they’re being polite?
  • There are automations for welcome messages, scheduled messages and inactivity rules. I haven’t touched them. Automating a hello feels odd to me, so that’s the next thing I’m going to try.
Prefer hiignite on Google Mark hiignite as a preferred source and these posts show up more often in your Google Search results. Add as preferred source

Coaching clients online?

hiignite is personal trainer and online coaching software: 30 days free, then Pro from $29/mo with 10 clients included, no per-message fees. Create an account, or get an email when we ship something worth reading.

// One email when we ship something worth reading. No spam.